> "J. Clarke"
> news:gfg1ne0f3d@news7.newsguy.com:
>
>> I had a coupon in my pocket and they had one left in stock, for 67
>> bucks how bad could it be?
>>
>> Turns out it's not bad at all. Sure, it's cheap and chintzy and you
>> have to be careful with setup, but it cranked up and ran fine out of
>> the box and can produce a decent edge fairly quickly. Not a superb
>> edge mind you, but one that a few passes on a hard arkansas stone can
>> finish up nicely.
>>
>> The stone holds a lot of water--I put a small nalgene bottle full in
>> the tray and the stone emptied it in about 30 seconds (note--I don't
>> mean it splashed it out, I mean it soaked it up). The second bottle
>> full filled it to the mark and the level pretty much stayed there.
>>
>> Overheating the tool is _not_ an issue--the edge is completely
>> immersed in water the whole time that sharpening is going on.
>>
>> I put some pictures of of it in operation and of the results at
>> http://www.flickr.com/photos/39383723@N00/sets/72157608992163168/.
>>
>>
>
> So, if you need to make a few passes on your hard Arkansas stone anyway,
> why not get a good grinder with a fairly fine wheel to put a pretty good
> edge on your tools, then make the final passes on the Arkansas stone?
> You already stated that you need to be careful with the setup, so why
> not just be careful when grinding? The dry grinder will be so much more
> versatile because you can put on different stones, and won't cost any
> more than the Tormek clone.
>
Because there's little danger of overheating the steel with a wet grinder?
Greg M

